We are all shocked about the extreme precipitation event which affected the Eifel region. I'm sure many in-depth analyses will follow in the next months.

Here I put some maps just to stimulate thought, not on the accuracy of the forecast itself, but on the synoptic situation which leads to this catastrophic event.

The approaching of a Rossby wave, later breaking in a cut-off low, generated heavy precip over central Europe, as often occurs in summer. However what is notable and usual here, is the stationarity of the low, the intensity of the precipitation and also the exceptional warm temperature anomaly of the air mass preceding the trough and then stagnating on the Baltic region.

As I tried to display in this EFI multiparameter map (left figure, below), there could be a direct connection between the intensity of precip on the Eifel region and the anomalously warm air mass still present to the northeast. The low-pressure area over central Europe is advecting low-level warm air from the northern side, generating the highest precipitation intensity on the western side of the cut-off low (this is quite unusual).  



The circulation of water vapour flux shows in fact a symmetric anomaly around the cut-off low (left figure, below), while usually, the largest positive anomalies are to the ascending branch. This, therefore, suggests an anomalous transport of water vapour over the western branch of the cut-off which could be linked to the temperature anomaly to the north. Cape was also anomalously high on the northern side of the low (right figure, below).


 


Although currently only speculative, it may be important to provide evidence of a direct and quantitative relationship between the temperature anomaly preceding this event and the intensity of precipitation in order also to show with concrete examples the increased likelihood of extreme events with global warming.


Finally, I include here for reference the observed precipitation maps produced by DWD.

6 Comments

  1. Thanks for the post, Federico. Here is the link to the Severe Event catalogue about the event: 202107 - Rainfall - Germany and Belgium

  2. Linus Magnusson Federico GrazziniI'm looking for the EFAS warnings made available to authorities in the July 10th-14th period, do you know if these are publicly available ?

    1. Please see statement made by Copernicus EMS regarding the warnings: https://emergency.copernicus.eu/mapping/ems/copernicus-emergency-management-service-forecasts-warns-and-monitors-devastating-floods-germany

      Data availability is described here: Data services

      For further questions, please contact the JRC directly.

      1. Thanks Florian. Unfortunately, without the actual content of the warnings, it is impossible to assess if the public authority did the right thing or not. I find it maddening that we would have to wait 30 days to have this data publicly available. In the meanwhile, our politicians are hiding behind "unimagined event", "way beyond the models", "no way we could have known", "we need better weather forecasting", etc..

        1. I fully understand your frustration.

          Maybe it helps that you can see all the products which are available to the national authorities here: EFAS products - so you can evaluate what type of information is available - the content of the warning itself is not really that relevant as most information/analysis is provided though this web service as it would not fit into a single email/notification (see page 34 for an example https://www.proteccioncivil.es/catalogo/naturales/gestion-riesgos-hidrometeorologicos/presentaciones/EFAS_Training_Spain_CP.pdf ).

          Unfortunately the question of data policy is not up to us and you need to contact the JRC ( JRC-PRESS@ec.europa.eu ) for further details  and ask them for the content of the warning. We are just the computational centre! The notifications and warnings are actually disseminated by other entities (check here:  https://confluence.ecmwf.int/display/COPSRV/EFAS+contributors ).

          Note that in general all data though the Copernicus Climate Change Service and Copernicus Atmospheric Monitoring Service which is operated by ECMWF on behalf of the commission are open. 

          1. Thanks. Super useful!